Who Makes The Call? A Tale in Two Stories

The Ban, the Tournament, and the Stakes

CueMasters Billiards, known for hosting the biggest pool tournaments, banned Alex “ShadowStriker” Lewis after a heated outburst during league play. Undeterred, Alex took his talent to SidePocket Lounge, where his team, the Nightblades, secured a spot in the QBL (Quality Billiards League) regional tournament. The twist? The event was to be held at CueMasters—his former stomping ground.

CueMasters thrived on league activity and tournaments, earning significant revenue from hosting. However, the QBL’s rules required fairness, meaning Alex’s team had to compete. If CueMasters refused to allow Alex, the QBL would relocate the tournament to SidePocket or another venue, costing CueMasters financially and straining their relationship with the league. Allowing Alex, however, risked their credibility with patrons and staff.

The QBL and CueMasters clashed. The QBL couldn’t ban Alex without compromising their integrity. CueMasters couldn’t risk alienating loyal customers. Both stood to lose, with tournament money and reputations on the line.

After tense negotiations, CueMasters agreed to let Alex play under conditions: he would publicly apologize, sign a strict conduct agreement, and adhere to a zero-tolerance policy during the event. CueMasters framed the decision as giving a talented player a chance at redemption while protecting their values.

The tournament proceeded at CueMasters, preserving relationships and ensuring a dramatic showdown—both on and off the tables.

The Deal, the Fallout, and the Resolution

Small artisan coffee roaster BeanWorks had built a reputation for premium, hand-roasted beans. A year ago, they struck a lucrative deal to supply their signature blends to FreshMart, a fast-growing grocery chain known for championing small businesses.

The partnership thrived until a delivery mishap led to BeanWorks missing an order deadline. FreshMart, valuing reliability above all else, cut ties with BeanWorks, replacing them with a competitor. Determined to recover, BeanWorks focused on expanding their online store and building relationships with local cafes.

Months later, FreshMart announced its “Local Heroes” marketing campaign, a flagship initiative showcasing small, artisan suppliers. BeanWorks’ reputation made them a perfect candidate, but FreshMart’s blacklist loomed over the possibility.

FreshMart’s campaign relied on credibility with customers, who expected authentic partnerships with small businesses. Excluding BeanWorks, a fan favorite, could undermine the campaign’s integrity. On the other hand, FreshMart risked backlash from corporate clients if they seemed too lenient on suppliers who had previously failed to deliver.

BeanWorks, though eager to participate, needed to balance the potential exposure against their brand’s values and the risk of being seen as overly dependent on a large corporate partner.

FreshMart faced a dilemma: include BeanWorks, risking perceptions of leniency, or stick to their policy and weaken the campaign’s appeal. BeanWorks, meanwhile, wrestled with how to reenter the partnership without appearing desperate or losing autonomy.

The two companies negotiated a middle ground. BeanWorks would rejoin FreshMart’s supplier list but under strict performance conditions, including clear deadlines and a backup fulfillment plan. FreshMart publicly framed the partnership as a commitment to supporting small businesses while ensuring quality and reliability for customers.

The campaign was a hit, and BeanWorks’ visibility skyrocketed, proving that trust and accountability could coexist in partnerships between small and big businesses.

Theme:

Despite previous underperformance or bad behavior, business will always be a negotiation between what you want more vs. yesterday's decisions. There is always a chance to be better than you were and with enough progress you may find doors open that were previously closed. Let SBA help you open doors for your business to both show and celebrate what you can do.